The proposals now competing disagree about almost everything except the starting point. The listing database is valuable because working brokers build it, one listing and one represented client at a time. Every proposal on the table is, at bottom, an argument about how to honor that fact
Arguments about real estate data are conducted in a specialized vocabulary, and the vocabulary is doing real work. These terms decide who may see your home listing, who may build products from your sale price, and who pays whom for what.
That trade has broken down, because some firms now take data out without putting listings in, and others want to hold listings back while staying in. In the summer of 2026, three documents from three organizations proposed three different repairs. Here they are, in plain language.
So the century old bargain now leaks at both ends. Firms that take everything out while putting nothing in. Firms that want to stay in while holding inventory back. And a new class of consumers who want the whole database for purposes the founders never dreamed of.
The database your neighborhood built is worth understanding, because everything about how homes are bought and sold runs through it.
A well capitalized brokerage underwriting a single MLS’s national footprint challenges the geographic MLS model that has organized this industry for a century. Every regional MLS should be discussing what that means for its market, its Participants and Subscribers, and its future.
THE LANGUAGE OF DATA SERIES | PART 7 OF 7 How Should Data Be Priced? Member uses at cost, commercial uses at market, and the
One habit will keep you oriented across all of these. For any feed, ask two questions. What may the recipient do with what arrives, that is the license. And is the output a listing being shown, or something new being made?
THE LANGUAGE OF DATA PART 4 OF 7 The Display Feeds: IDX, VOW, and Publisher The three feeds that show listings to human beings:
The grey market is not the black market of outright theft. It is the sprawl of MLS data circulating in ways nobody quite licensed and nobody can quite trace: the vendor feed that keeps running after the client relationship ends; the full payload delivered for one purpose and quietly repurposed for another; copies passed downstream to sub vendors and partners the license never named; over retained historical data reborn as someone’s analytics product; exported records laundered into tools and lists far from their source.
If you were ever going to pull your listings from the major portals, this market is the time to take back your future. MLS and
In 2024, it’s all about being clear, helpful, and adding value wherever you can. Use this graphic to reinforce that message, and watch your client connections grow stronger.
This Post summarizes the 4 major cases against NAR, MLSs, Franchises, and Brokerage firms. Damages for these cases have been estimated in the Billions of dollars,
Get up to the minute updates and resources.
